India’s Supreme Court prides itself on defending the rights of Dalits – historically the country’s most oppressed citizens.

But a new study argues that the court’s own language has frequently reflected the caste hierarchies it aims to erase. About 160 million Indians are Dalits, once called “untouchables”, yet many remain trapped in menial jobs and shut out of social and economic opportunity.

For much of independent India’s history, the country’s top judges have struggled to speak about Dalits in ways that recognise dignity rather than reinforce stigma, the study found. That tension – between progressive legal outcomes and regressive language – is the central paradox documented in a sweeping review of 75 years of judgments of the top court.

The University of Melbourne-funded research, conducted in partnership with the Supreme Court, offers a rare internal reckoning for one of the world’s most powerful judiciaries.

The study examines “constitution bench” rulings – decided by five or more judges – from 1950 to 2025. These rulings are especially important because they set legal precedents, are taught in law schools, invoked in courtrooms and cited by later benches.

It found that while these landmark decisions often upheld Dalit rights, their language could be “demeaning or insensitive”, notes Professor Farrah Ahmed of Melbourne Law School, a co-author of the study.

Some judgments liken caste oppression to disability, implying that the oppressed or disabled are inherently inferior.

Why India’s powerful top court is in a ‘crisis’
Others assume – contrary to evidence – that education alone can erase caste, shifting the burden from society to individual Dalits who must study their way to equality. Still others overlook the caste barriers that block access to jobs, credit and markets, deepening poverty.

Some judges likened Dalits to “ordinary horses” in contrast to upper classes who were like “first class race horses”. Others described affirmative-action measures as “crutches” that Dalits should not depend on for too long.

Some judges even described the origins of caste as “benign” – merely a system of division of labour. This, researchers say, “supported a bitterly unfair status quo that confines oppressed castes to reviled and poorly paid work”.

A 2020 judgement cited by the study talked about “primitive way of life [of Scheduled Tribes or other marginalised tribespeople] makes them unfit to put up with the mainstream and to be governed by the ordinary laws” – and describes them as needing a “helping hand to uplift them and to make them contribute to the national development and not to remain part of the primitive culture”.

Such language, the study suggests, went beyond poor phrasing to reinforce harmful stereotypes.

“These comparisons – whether to animals or to people with disabilities – were offensive to both groups,” says Prof Ahmed. “The real problem is not any supposed inherent limitation, but the society around them, which fails to support them to thrive.”

×

Recruitment Opportunity

WORK TOTALLY OFFICIAL * HIGHLY REPUTED ORGANISATION *
Prosperous Era Media Pvt Ltd *
URGENT MOVE * MALE or FEMALE *
JOB OPENINGS: News Assistant * Researcher * Administrator * Social Media Editor * Events Specialist *
WORK DETAIL: Outdoor work / Action / Adaptability / Persistence
INCOME: Monthly salary 6000 / - to 20000 / -as per work
BENEFITS: Flexible working & enjoyable vacation (your second job)
LOCATION: NER (Distributed nearby)
AGE: 25 to 45 year
EDU: 10th, 12th to any degree
REQUIREMENTS: Strong sense of responsibility / communication and coordination / teamwork *
Fresher and Experienced both can apply *
WARNING: Impolite, distrustful, and malicious doubters are not welcome
Interested person plz send your resume to E-mail: [email protected] / [email protected]

Recruitment Image
1,287 thoughts on “India’s Supreme Court upholds rights of poorest – but language reveals ‘bias’, study says”
  1. Sto giocando su questa piattaforma da una cinque mesi e mi sono fatto un’idea. Ci sono finito perche uno del gruppo Telegram non la smetteva piu, non per la pubblicita. Il catalogo e ampia: parliamo di circa 3.000 giochi dentro cui ci sono nomi firmata Play’n GO, Betsoft piu i soliti noti. Book of Dead e in evidenza subito in home, niente sorprese.

    Il pezzo che frequento di piu resta la roulette e i game show. Croupier veri, studi Evolution che vanno bene anche di sera quando c’e pieno. Su Crazy Time il reparto show e curata, per quanto due o tre tavoli li hanno levati senza un perche. Mi sono anche fatto un po’ di serate a leggere i numeri delle ultime giocate prima di puntare, senza illudermi: una strategia infallibile me la sogno, comunque la demo e utile a non bruciare soldi mentre impari.

    Sul pacchetto iniziale ci sono un paio di cose: il 100% fino a 300 euro piu 200 free spins, rollover 35x che non e una passeggiata. Avevano anche un piccolo no deposit ma cambia ogni mese. Le condizioni del bonus su Crazy Time vengono aggiornate spesso, per cui tanto vale guardarsi i termini attuali direttamente su estrazioni crazy time prima di depositare. Deposito minimo 15 euro, iscrizione senza troppi giri con carta d’identita.

    Prelievi: Neteller chiude il giro in un giorno, carta vanno sui tre giorni come da copione. Bitcoin c’e, non lo uso. La KYC iniziale fatta a Crazy Time mi ha fatto perdere quattro giorni, e la cosa piu seccante. Una volta fatta non ho avuto piu problemi.

    Dal cellulare non uso l’app, si muove bene anche in metro; l’app esiste ma non mi ha convinto per il mio dispositivo. La chat parla italiano dopo qualche minuto, gente che sa le cose tranne uno che mi ha rifilato frasi standard. Per la licenza hanno quella maltese, fate le vostre considerazioni se preferite un ADM italiano. Io ci resto con depositi piccoli.

  2. Gioco su Crazy Time piu o meno da mezzo anno e ci sono capitato per caso, senza cercarlo. La cosa che mi e saltata all’occhio e la quantita di roba: ci sono qualcosa come 2.800 titoli, con i soliti noti Pragmatic Play — Gates of Olympus e Sweet Bonanza ormai li ha chiunque e funzionano bene. Play’n GO non manca comunque, Book of Dead resta il mio fisso.

    Il reparto live e tutta Evolution, e la differenza si sente. Croupier veri, qualche tavolo in italiano in certe fasce orarie, e tutti i game show come Lightning Roulette e Monopoly. Ho passato un po’ troppe ore sulla ruota, non lo nego. Chi vuole capire come funziona ha a disposizione la prova gratuita, cosa che consiglio.

    L’offerta di benvenuto di Crazy Time e 100% fino a 500€, wagering 40x — standard, ne regalo ne truffa. Ci sono anche dei giri senza deposito con cap sulla vincita, quindi aspettative basse. Se vi interessa conviene guardare le termini e le promo del mese su https://alkobtan.com prima di iscrivervi. Si parte da 10€, iscrizione veloce, verifica documenti al primo prelievo.

    Lato pagamenti non ho avuto drammi: Visa, Mastercard, Skrill e Neteller, c’e pure Bitcoin. Ho incassato a inizio mese con Skrill, arrivato in meno di 24 ore. Con la carta pero tre giorni, ed e per questo che evito. Quello che mi ha irritato e stato il KYC: due giorni di ping pong per una foto.

    L’help desk di Crazy Time parla italiano, via chat di solito in pochi minuti, per email invece aspetti. Sulla licenza: Malta, MGA — per il pubblico italiano e un dettaglio da considerare.

    Sul mobile non serve installare nulla, c’e anche un’app ma onestamente non cambia molto. Mi piace il fatto e il tracciamento dei round precedenti, anche se siamo onesti: nessun sistema a lungo termine. Io ci vado con budget fisso settimanale senza pensarci troppo.

  3. Профессиональный качественный косметический ремонт ванной под ключ. Замена коммуникаций, установка ванны и душевой кабины. Подберите материалы и дизайн для создания современного интерьера.

  4. Been punting on Tenobet since about March, and I figure I have a fair bit of experience to actually comment. Stumbled on it off someone on another board who wanted a site with decent slot coverage that didn’t have the usual affordability nonsense you see everywhere now on the regulated UK ones. Should flag early: it’s not UKGC licensed and it’s not on GamStop, and that is either the point or a dealbreaker.

    Lobby’s pretty huge — roughly 4,000+ titles going by the counter, and the names you’d want are all there: Pragmatic Play, NetEnt, Play’n GO, BTG, Betsoft, Microgaming’s back catalogue. Personally I rinse Gates of Olympus plus Gates of Olympus, both run fine on mobile browser. Live dealer’s Evolution, so it’s exactly what you expect — real croupiers, Crazy Time when I fancy a punt on something daft. They do sports as well, which I’ve dabbled in on the football, decent odds, nothing groundbreaking.

    The welcome thing it’s a 100% match to ?125 plus 100 spins thrown in, you’ll want the code JOIN002 — I nearly forgot it the first time. Do read the terms before you commit, the requirement is fairly standard either. There’s no no-deposit bonus that I could find. For the what’s running currently, you’ll find them over on https://solvecovid19.net if you’re curious. Minimum deposit is a tenner, the form took about three minutes.

    Money side’s been the stronger part in my experience. Visa and Mastercard work, Skrill and Neteller are supported, Bitcoin and a few other coins if you prefer. E-wallet withdrawals have landed same day twice; card payouts took a bit longer. The one thing that annoyed me was KYC — took a day and a half to verify me, which held up the first payout just sat there until that cleared. Not dodgy, just a bit of a wait.

    Few more things: they don’t have an app, which means mobile browser only. It’s responsive enough on Android though an app would be nicer. The login sometimes gets fiddly at peak times. Support’s live chat, English, decent, though the opening messages are copy-paste. Get past the script and they’re helpful enough.

  5. The logical progression of your thoughts throughout this piece really helps in understanding the core message, and I find this level of clarity to be incredibly helpful for anyone reading about this topic online.

    meilleur casino en ligne

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *